Today there was a presentation and "youth consultation" by the Canadian Zinc Corporation. At issue is their proposal to develop a silver/lead/zinc mine at Prairie Creek, about 60km upriver from Nahanni Butte and in the heart of the expanded Nahanni National Park Reserve.

They made a slick case, as you might expect, and appear to be going through all the right motions of consultation with the communities concerned. And who knows, if the project goes ahead they might indeed be able to avoid damaging the pristine environment.
But beyond the nasty thought of a mine operating in the heart of a UNESCO World Heritage site is the consequences the development will have on Nahanni Butte. Today they were preaching the usual mantra of jobs, jobs, jobs - but this is a mine that is expected to operate for a decade or so at most. Even if their rosy picture comes to pass, what will happen after production ends?
Many of their development ideas are questionable - they are talking of sticking cellphone towers on the local mountains out of the goodness of their hearts. So what if place of this size has no need for mobile phones - I'm sure the mining crews wouldn't mind it. Even more troubling is the suggestion of setting up a pitstop in town for the truckers working the winter road. I don't care how they dress it up, that will only result in an influx of drugs and alcohol. Not to mention a suspicious spike in the number of children enrolling in school a few years down the line. All you need to do is look at other small communities around the Territory to see what this sort of development will do to Nahanni Butte.
I have been reluctant to voice these thoughts too loudly around the locals because ultimately it is not my decision, and the last thing these people need is another meddling white man telling them what they should or should not do. It is especially tricky because the fact remains that aside from projects like Prairie Creek, there are virtually no other alternatives on the horizon for local employment. But I must admit that I am somewhat reassured to see that there is a great deal of scepticism about the project within the community. I was gratified to see some of the people present at the meeting today ask tough questions.
The whole episode has highlighted a difficult question for me: I want to be involved in this community, but to what extent do I have a 'right' to offer my opinion on local issues? I am working hard to be accepted here, but I still feel I have a way to go before I will have paid my dues.